Discussion of the Young’s Statement

Cite this

Self-Contradictory of Young’s Statement

Social justice theory is on the rise in the current Western social science discourse. However, it is not without its flaws. The statement about unintentional oppression that Young made in her book, which can be considered a significant contribution to the theory of social justice, contradicts itself. Firstly, the question arises of who these many oppressive individuals are. Young did not clarify these groups of individuals.

Cut 15% OFF your first order
We’ll deliver a custom Public Policy paper tailored to your requirements with a good discount
Use discount
322 specialists online

In the theory of social justice, there is a dichotomy between oppressors and oppressed in human society. The concept of social justice is closely related to intersectionality. In intersectional theory, social identities can be both oppressive and suppressed. It means that those many individuals mentioned by Young are not agents of oppression only; they are also oppressed. The concept of the social relationship that Young described must be revised.

Another Paradox of Young’s Statement

The writer also argues that oppressive actions are conscious. However, she further notes that simple daily activities and practices reproduce oppression. Young’s statement is paradoxical in its nature. Oppression cannot be unintentional; it is always a deliberate practice. Therefore, the lifestyle of many people cannot be viewed as oppressive. It is necessary to mention that it is immoral to accuse entire groups of individuals of oppression.

It is also counterintuitive especially given the above arguments. Social justice theory is a promising concept, but like any new idea, it needs a significant theoretical background, the principle of consistency and self-criticism. Perhaps in the future, social justice and intersectionality theories would give people the necessary means to solve many social, political, and economic problems. Nowadays, both of them need to be given more time to develop as disciplines of philosophy and social sciences.

Cite this paper

Select style

Reference

DemoEssays. (2022, June 8). Discussion of the Young's Statement. Retrieved from https://demoessays.com/discussion-of-the-youngs-statement/

Reference

DemoEssays. (2022, June 8). Discussion of the Young's Statement. https://demoessays.com/discussion-of-the-youngs-statement/

Work Cited

"Discussion of the Young's Statement." DemoEssays, 8 June 2022, demoessays.com/discussion-of-the-youngs-statement/.

References

DemoEssays. (2022) 'Discussion of the Young's Statement'. 8 June.

References

DemoEssays. 2022. "Discussion of the Young's Statement." June 8, 2022. https://demoessays.com/discussion-of-the-youngs-statement/.

1. DemoEssays. "Discussion of the Young's Statement." June 8, 2022. https://demoessays.com/discussion-of-the-youngs-statement/.


Bibliography


DemoEssays. "Discussion of the Young's Statement." June 8, 2022. https://demoessays.com/discussion-of-the-youngs-statement/.