Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences

Introduction

Following the 9/11 terrorist attacks in the United States, the war in Afghanistan began on October 7, 2001. The primary goal of the war was to demolish the Taliban government, which was accused of sheltering Al-Qaeda militants who carried out the assaults. For 20 years, thousands of US soldiers were stationed in Afghanistan. The American departure from Afghanistan has been compared to the disorderly retreat from Saigon in 1973, which resulted in the collapse of South Vietnam to North Vietnamese communist troops.

Description of the Conflict

The need for better preparation and coordination is one of the primary similarities between the American departure from Afghanistan and the disastrous retreat from Saigon. There was haste to evacuate US forces and their allies in both situations, resulting in a fast and disorganized departure (Cordesman, 2019). The lack of planning was caused by the US underestimating the enemy’s power and dedication in both cases. The Taliban had been gaining territory in Afghanistan for months before the US pullout, but the US government did not take the danger seriously (Cordesman, 2019). Similarly, the Americans miscalculated the power of the Viet Cong and the North Vietnamese Army in Vietnam, resulting in a decade-long conflict.

Impact on Civilians

Another parallel between the two events is the impact on civilians. The retreat caused a humanitarian disaster in all cases, with thousands of people seeking sanctuary and protection. In Afghanistan, the abrupt withdrawal of US forces exposed thousands of Afghans who had cooperated for the US government or its allies to Taliban retaliation (Cordesman, 2019). Similarly, the withdrawal of US soldiers from Vietnam left many South Vietnamese citizens at the mercy of communist forces.

Involvement of Technology

Nonetheless, there are notable contrasts between the US departure from Afghanistan and the fall of Saigon. The involvement of technology in the two battles is a crucial distinction. Drones and other high-tech military equipment allowed the US to conduct targeted strikes on Taliban and Al-Qaeda commanders in Afghanistan (Cordesman, 2019). Despite its technological supremacy, the United States could not win the hearts and minds of the Afghan people, who perceived the US presence as an occupation. The US depended on traditional military methods in Vietnam, such as air strikes and ground offensives, which were ineffectual against the highly mobile and adaptive Viet Cong.

Political Setting

Another distinction between the two battles is their political setting. The Vietnam War was a component of the more significant Cold War confrontation between the United States and the Soviet Union (Cordesman, 2019). The United States considered its engagement in Vietnam as a means of controlling the spread of communism. On the other hand, the War in Afghanistan was initiated as part of the War on Terror to prevent terrorist strikes against the United States and its allies (Cordesman, 2019). A coalition of NATO and non-NATO nations offered military and financial assistance to the American engagement in Afghanistan.

With the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the United States became involved in Afghanistan. The assaults were carried out by Al-Qaeda, an Afghan-based terrorist organization commanded by Osama bin Laden. The Taliban administration, which controlled most of Afghanistan, refused to deliver over bin Laden, prompting the US-led invasion of Afghanistan in October 2001 (Cordesman, 2019). The US-led coalition successfully deposed Taliban rule, but the war became prolonged when the Taliban started an insurgency against the US-backed government.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the US withdrawal from Afghanistan has been compared to the chaotic withdrawal from Saigon in 1973. While the two events share certain parallels, there are substantial distinctions in technology, political background, and regional actors. The Afghan war began with the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 and was part of the broader War on Terror. The US and its allies encountered obstacles in gaining the Afghan people’s support and establishing a functional Afghan government and security forces. The United States’ withdrawal from Afghanistan has sparked worries about the future of human rights and the region’s chances for peace and security.

Reference

Cordesman, A. H. (2019). Afghanistan as Vietnam redux: Bomb, declare peace, and leave? CSIS.

Cite this paper

Select style

Reference

DemoEssays. (2024, October 19). Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences. https://demoessays.com/comparing-the-us-withdrawals-from-afghanistan-and-saigon-similarities-and-differences/

Work Cited

"Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences." DemoEssays, 19 Oct. 2024, demoessays.com/comparing-the-us-withdrawals-from-afghanistan-and-saigon-similarities-and-differences/.

References

DemoEssays. (2024) 'Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences'. 19 October.

References

DemoEssays. 2024. "Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences." October 19, 2024. https://demoessays.com/comparing-the-us-withdrawals-from-afghanistan-and-saigon-similarities-and-differences/.

1. DemoEssays. "Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences." October 19, 2024. https://demoessays.com/comparing-the-us-withdrawals-from-afghanistan-and-saigon-similarities-and-differences/.


Bibliography


DemoEssays. "Comparing the US Withdrawals from Afghanistan and Saigon: Similarities and Differences." October 19, 2024. https://demoessays.com/comparing-the-us-withdrawals-from-afghanistan-and-saigon-similarities-and-differences/.